6.1 Clinical Trials Experience
Because clinical trials are conducted under widely varying conditions, adverse reaction rates observed in the clinical trials of a vaccine cannot be directly compared with rates in the clinical trials of another vaccine, and may not reflect the rates observed in practice. There is the possibility that broad use of JYNNEOS could reveal adverse reactions not observed in clinical trials.
Safety data accrued with the one-vial presentation is relevant to the two-vial presentation because each contains the same live, attenuated, non-replicating orthopoxvirus and is manufactured using a similar process.
The overall clinical trial program included 23 studies (14 studies with the one-vial presentation, 7 studies with the two-vial presentation, and 2 studies with both one-vial and two-vial presentations) and a total of 8,988 participants 18 through 80 years of age who received at least 1 dose of JYNNEOS (8,222 smallpox vaccine-naïve and 766 smallpox vaccine-experienced participants). Of the 8,988 participants, 6,459 participants received the one-vial presentation and 2,529 participants received the two-vial presentation.
Solicited Adverse Reactions
Solicited Adverse Reactions in Smallpox Vaccine-Naïve Individuals:
The safety of JYNNEOS one-vial presentation in smallpox vaccine-naïve participants was evaluated in Study 1 [1], a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study conducted in the US in which vaccinia-naïve adults ages 18 to 40 years received either two doses of JYNNEOS (N=3,003), or two injections of Tris-Buffered Saline (placebo, N=1,002) four weeks apart.
In the total study population, the mean age was 28 years; 47.9% of the participants were men; 77.4% were white/Caucasian, 17.8% black/African American, 1.9% Asian, 0.5% American Indian/Alaska Native, 0.4% Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific, 1.9% other racial groups; and 11.4% of participants were of Hispanic/Latino ethnicity. The demographic distribution was similar in the JYNNEOS and placebo groups.
In Study 1, participants were monitored for local and systemic adverse reactions using diary cards for an 8-day period starting on the day of each vaccination. The frequencies of solicited local and systemic adverse reactions following any dose of JYNNEOS are presented in Table 1.
In Study 1, the majority of solicited local and systemic adverse reactions reported with JYNNEOS had a median duration of 1 to 6 days. In general, there were similar proportions of participants reporting solicited local or systemic reactions of any severity after Dose 2 of JYNNEOS compared with Dose 1, with the exception of injection site pain, which was more commonly reported following Dose 1 (79.3%) than Dose 2 (69.9%).
The two presentations of JYNNEOS (one-vial and two-vial) were compared in Study 2 [2], a randomized, double-blind, multicenter study conducted in the US in which vaccinia-naïve adults ages 18 to 55 years received two doses of either two-vial presentation (N=325) or one-vial presentation (N=327) JYNNEOS four weeks apart.
The mean age was approximately 28 years for both study groups; 46.5% of the participants were men; 74.7% were White/Caucasian, 22.3% Black/African American, 0.8% Oriental/Asian, 0.2% American Indian/Alaska Native, 0.3% Native Hawaiian/ Pacific Islander, 1.5% multiple racial groups, and 0.3% other racial groups; and 29.2% of participants were of Hispanic/Latino ethnicity. The demographic distribution was similar in the two JYNNEOS treatment groups.
In Study 2, participants were monitored for local and systemic adverse reactions for an 8-day period starting on the day of each vaccination. The frequencies of solicited local and systemic adverse reactions following any dose of JYNNEOS are presented in Table 2.
In Study 2, solicited systemic adverse reactions reported with both presentations had a similar median duration of 1 to 3 days. Solicited local adverse reactions reported with both presentations had a similar median duration of 4 to 6 days, except for injection site induration. The median duration of injection site induration was 11 days for the one-vial presentation and 14 days for the two-vial presentation.
Solicited Adverse Reactions in Persons Previously Vaccinated with a Smallpox Vaccine:
Three studies (Study 3, Study 4, and Study 5 [3-5]) conducted in the US and Germany evaluated the safety of JYNNEOS one-vial presentation in 409 persons previously vaccinated with a smallpox vaccine who received one or two doses of JYNNEOS (mean age 39 years, range 20-80 years; 59% women; 98.8% white/Caucasian; 0.7% Asian; 0.5% black/African American). Participants were monitored for local and systemic adverse reactions using diary cards for an 8-day period starting on the day of each vaccination. Across all three studies, solicited local adverse reactions reported following any dose of JYNNEOS were redness (80.9%), pain (79.5%), induration (70.4%), swelling (67.2%), and itching (32.0%) at the injection site; solicited systemic adverse reactions reported following any dose of JYNNEOS were fatigue (33.5%), headache (27.6%), muscle pain (21.5%), nausea (9.8%), chills (0.7%), and fever (0.5%).
Solicited Adverse Reactions in HIV-infected Individuals:
The safety of JYNNEOS one-vial presentation in HIV-infected participants was evaluated in Study 6 [6], an open label trial conducted in the US that included 351 HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve participants, 131 HIV-infected participants who previously received smallpox vaccine, 88 non-HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve participants and 9 non-HIV-infected participants who had previously received a smallpox vaccine. The demographic distribution (race, ethnicity, and sex) of HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve participants and those who had previously received smallpox vaccine were similar and overall were 17.0% women; 45.8% white/Caucasian; 0.4% Asian; 33.2% black/African American; 19.0% Hispanic/Latino ethnicity; the HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve group tended to be younger (mean age 37 years) compared to those who had previously received a smallpox vaccine (mean age 45 years). Participants had CD4 counts ≥ 200 and ≤ 750 cells/μL at study entry.
Solicited local and systemic adverse reactions were reported at similar or lower frequencies in HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve participants as compared to those seen in non-HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naive participants in this study.
In HIV-infected participants with previous smallpox vaccine exposure, fever and chills were reported in 1.5% and 8.4% of participants respectively. Frequencies of other solicited local and systemic adverse reactions in this population were similar to those reported in Studies 3-5 in non-HIV-infected participants who had previously received smallpox vaccination.
The safety of JYNNEOS two-vial presentation in HIV-infected participants was evaluated in Study 7 [7], an open label trial conducted in the US that included 30 HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve participants, 61 HIV-infected participants who previously received smallpox vaccine, 30 non-HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve participants, and 30 non-HIV-infected participants who had previously received a smallpox vaccine. The demographic distribution (race, ethnicity, and sex) of HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve participants and those who had previously received smallpox vaccine were similar. Overall for HIV-infected participants, 29.7% of participants were women; 58.2% were white/Caucasian; 40.7% black/African American; 1.1% other race; Hispanic/Latino ethnicity was not reported; the HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve group tended to be younger (mean age approximately 31 years) compared to those who had previously received a smallpox vaccine (mean age approximately 43 years). Participants had CD4 counts > 350 cells/μL at study entry.
Solicited local and systemic adverse reactions were reported at similar or lower frequencies in HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naïve participants as compared to those seen in non-HIV-infected smallpox vaccine-naive participants who received the two-vial presentation in this study with the exception of fatigue (40.7% HIV-infected, 36.7% non-HIV infected).
Study 7 also evaluated the safety of a single dose of JYNNEOS two-vial presentation in 61 HIV-infected participants who previously received a smallpox vaccine and 30 non-HIV-infected participants who previously received a smallpox vaccine. Overall for participants who previously received a smallpox vaccine, the mean age was approximately 44 years, range 35-55 years; 44% women; 63.7% white/Caucasian; 34.1% black/African American; 2.2% other race. Participants were monitored for local and systemic adverse reactions for an 8-day period starting on the day of each vaccination. Solicited local adverse reactions reported among both HIV-infected and non HIV-infected participants previously vaccinated with a smallpox vaccine following a single dose of JYNNEOS two-vial presentation were redness (54.9%), pain (84.6%), induration (38.5%), swelling (45.1%), and itching (18.7%) at the injection site; solicited systemic adverse reactions reported following any dose of JYNNEOS were fatigue (38.5%), headache (37.4%), muscle pain (42.9%), nausea (27.5%), chills (16.5%), and fever (2.2%).
In HIV-infected participants with previous smallpox vaccine exposure who received the two-vial presentation, solicited local and systemic adverse reactions were reported at similar or lower frequencies compared to those reported in non-HIV-infected participants who previously received smallpox vaccination in this study.
Solicited Adverse Reactions in Individuals with Atopic Dermatitis:
The safety of JYNNEOS one-vial presentation in smallpox vaccine-naïve participants with currently active or a history of atopic dermatitis (AD) was evaluated in a multicenter, open-label clinical study (Study 8 [8]) conducted in the US and Mexico that included 350 participants with AD and 282 participants without AD. In the overall study the mean age of participants was 27 years (range 18-42 years), and participants were 59.0% women, 39.4% white/Caucasian, 10.9% Asian, 9.0% black/African American, 2.2% Other, and 38.4% Hispanic/Latino ethnicity. Demographic distribution was similar between participants with and without AD. In participants with AD, solicited local and systemic adverse reactions were reported at similar frequencies as those in participants without AD in this study, with the exception of redness (61.2% with AD vs. 49.3% without AD), swelling (52.2% with AD vs. 40.8% without AD), chills (15.9% with AD vs. 7.8% without AD) and headache (47.2% with AD vs. 34.8% without AD).
The safety of JYNNEOS two-vial presentation in smallpox vaccine-naïve participants with currently active or a history of atopic dermatitis (AD) was evaluated in an open-label, controlled clinical study (Study 9 [9]) conducted in Germany that included 31 participants with AD and 29 participants without AD. In the overall study, the mean age was approximately 25 years (range 19-34 years), and participants were 48.3% women, 95% white/Caucasian, 3.3% Asian, 1.7% black/African American; Hispanic/Latino ethnicity was not reported. The demographic distribution was similar between participants with AD and participants without AD. In participants with AD, solicited local and systemic adverse reactions were reported at similar frequencies as those in participants without AD in this study.
The following solicited local and systemic adverse reactions were reported at a greater frequency in participants with AD than those without AD in this study: redness (96.8% with AD vs. 89.7% without AD), itching (25.8% with AD vs. 13.8% without AD), fatigue (67.7% with AD vs. 51.7% without AD), headache (54.8% with AD vs. 44.8% without AD), myalgia (29% with AD vs. 24.1% without AD), and nausea (16.1% with AD vs. 10.3% without AD).
Serious Adverse Events
The integrated analyses of serious adverse events (SAEs) pooled safety data across 23 studies, which included a total of 8,222 smallpox vaccine-naïve participants and 766 smallpox vaccine-experienced participants who received at least 1 dose of JYNNEOS and 1,219 smallpox vaccine-naïve participants and 1 smallpox vaccine-experienced participant who received placebo only. SAEs were monitored from the day of the first study vaccination through at least 6 months after the last study vaccination.
Overall, SAEs were reported to occur in 1.5% (136/8,988) of JYNNEOS (one-vial or two-vial presentation) recipients and 1.4% (17/1,220) of placebo recipients. Among the smallpox vaccine-naïve participants, SAEs were reported for 1.3% (78/5,805) of JYNNEOS one-vial presentation recipients, 1.7% (40/2,417) of JYNNEOS two-vial presentation participants, and 1.4% (17/1,219) of placebo recipients. Among the smallpox vaccine-experienced participants enrolled in studies, SAEs were reported for 2.3% (15/654) of JYNNEOS one-vial presentation recipients and 2.7% (3/112) of JYNNEOS two-vial presentation recipients. Across all studies, a causal relationship to JYNNEOS could not be excluded for 5 SAEs, all non-fatal, which included Crohn’s disease, sarcoidosis, extraocular muscle paresis, throat tightness, and hemolytic anemia.
Cardiac Adverse Events of Special Interest
Evaluation of cardiac adverse events of special interest (AESIs) included any cardiac signs or symptoms, ECG changes determined to be clinically significant, or troponin-I elevated above 2 times the upper limit of normal. In the 23 studies, participants were monitored for cardiac-related signs or symptoms through at least 6 months after the last vaccination.
The numbers of JYNNEOS and placebo recipients, respectively, with troponin-I data were: baseline level (7,505 and 1,203); level two weeks after first dose (6,284 and 1,166); level two weeks after second dose (1,684 and 193); unscheduled visit, including for clinical evaluation of suspected cardiac adverse events (501 and 60).
Overall, cardiac AESIs were reported to occur in 1.3% (112/8,988) of JYNNEOS (one-vial or two-vial presentation) recipients and 0.2% (3/1,220) of placebo recipients. The higher proportion of JYNNEOS one-vial presentation recipients who experienced cardiac AESIs was driven by 28 cases of asymptomatic post-vaccination elevation of troponin-I in two studies: Study 6, which enrolled 482 HIV-infected participants and 97 healthy participants, and Study 8, which enrolled 350 participants with atopic dermatitis and 282 healthy participants. An additional 127 cases of asymptomatic post-vaccination elevation of troponin-I above the upper limit of normal but not above 2 times the upper limit of normal were documented in JYNNEOS recipients throughout the clinical development program, 124 of which occurred in Study 6 and Study 8. Proportions of participants with troponin-I elevations were similar between healthy and HIV-infected participants in Study 6 and between healthy and atopic dermatitis participants in Study 8. A different troponin assay was used in these two studies compared to the other studies, and these two studies had no placebo controls. The clinical significance of these asymptomatic post-vaccination elevations of troponin-I is unknown.
Among the cardiac AESIs reported, 6 cases (<0.1%) were considered to be causally related to JYNNEOS vaccination and included tachycardia, electrocardiogram T wave inversion, electrocardiogram abnormal, electrocardiogram ST segment elevation, electrocardiogram T wave abnormal, and palpitations.
None of the cardiac AESIs considered causally related to study vaccination were considered serious.